Please find below the minutes from 25 May 2021

Participants: Paloma Arillo Aranda (OP), Cécile Guasch (ISA2 - DIGIT), Hilde Kjolset (dfø), Giorgia Lodi (ISTC-CNR), Natalie Muric (OP) and Giampaolo Sellitto (ANAC).

Due to unavailability of a part of the WG members the meeting on 20 May 2021 was cancelled.

Topic of discussion: SPARQL Queries analysis

  • Possible error detected: superfluous 'P' HTML element in the queries. This is not a real error as it was requested to be added to the text in order to separate the sentences with paragraphs.

  • Link: if we have the Procedure ID it should not be a problem to launch a query to map TED data with the National ID for that procedure. Queries will have to be adapted and finetuned to meet Procedure without corresponding ID.

  • epo:identifierValue should be epo:hasIdentifierValue

  • epo:isResponsiblityOf should be isResponsibilityOf

  • How could we detect the possible spelling mistakes in the mapping in order to correct them to run the SPARQL queries. Maybe with SHACL Shapes?

Action Points

  • Look into ways of treating paragraphs in pdf

  • epo:insert verbs infront of attributes instead of using has by default

Topic of discussion: Definitions – predicates

The following relations were discussed and compared with the html conventions to see if this work will correct the inconsistencies:

  • Subject: AwardDecision

Predicate: refersTo

Object: Lot, LotGroup

AwardDecision is a Document. The WG checks the reification. It is decided to keep it as it is as it will be used for version 2.0.1

  • Subject: Contract

Predicate: refersTo

Object: Lot

Contract is a Document. The WG decides that is probably should follow the reification. To be discussed

  • Subject: Contract

Predicate: refersTo

Object: Tender

Definition: Realtion indicating a document mentions another document.

Contract is a Document. Tender is a Document.

  • Subject: ContractModificationNotice

Predicate: ‘refersTo’ replaced with ‘Modifies’

Object: ContractAwardNotice

Definition: Realtion indicatin a ContractModificationNotice announces a modification of a contract.

ContractModificationNotice is a Document. ContractAwardNotice is a Document.

  • Subject: PlannedProcurementPart

Predicate: refersTo

Object: Document

To be checked if this relation can be deleted when doing a new mapping.

  • Subject: ‘TenderLot’ replaced with ‘Tender’

Predicate: ‘refersTo’ replaced with ‘specifiesItem’ and this replaced with 'itemises'

Object: Item

Definition: Relation indicating a tender or a lot details an item

Inverse: itemItemisedBy

Definition: Relation indicating an item is detailes in a tender or lot

  • Subject: Lot

Predicate: ‘refersTo’ replaced with ‘specifiesItem’ and this replaced with 'itemises'

Object: Item

Definition: Relation indicating a tender or lot details an item

Inverse: itemItemisedBy

Definition: Relation indicating an item is detailes in a tender or lot

  • Subject: Lot

Predicate: ‘refersTo’ replaced with ‘isDerivedFrom’

Object: PlannedProcurementPart

Definition: relation indicating from where the lot stems

Inverse: becomes

Definition: Relation indicating a PlannedProcurementPlan becomes a lot or a procedure

  • Subject: Document

Predicate: relatesTo

Object: Procedure

Definition: Relation indicating a document used in the context of a procedure

  • Subject: TenderLot

Predicate: 'relatesTo' replaced with 'isSubmittedFor'

Object: Lot

Definition: Relation indicating a TenderLot is submitted for a lot

  • Subject: Lot

Predicate: specifies

Object: 'SelectionCriterion' replaced with 'ProcedureCriterion'

  • Subject: Procedure

Predicate: isComposedOf

Object: Lot