Working Group meeting

Date: 07/11/2023
Participants: Asma Adala, Paloma Arillo, Guillaume Jacquet, Giovanni Paolo Sellitto, Pascaline Laure Tchienehom, Cristian Vasquez
Model editor: Andreea Pasăre
Note editor: Natalie Muric

Agenda

  • Modelling of ELI

  • eAccess:

    • Subcriterion

    • Information Requirement: Requirements and questions

Modelling of ELI

The modelling of ELI was presented. It was noted that ELI includes Manifestation concept, which is not required within eAccess.
It was discussed that ELI will be imported into the ontology and the concepts required will be reused and not customised:

RPRNLKgjw7948jEGACIiOm0YAIiI6A+1qNfFnAWa6FtgACAiotOGAYCIiP5Q4nW4iU6C6N9NIiKivzoGACIiIiIiIqJTgAGAiIiIiIiI6BRgACAiIiIiIiI6BRgAiIiIiIiIiE4BBgAiIiIiIiKiU+BvG+JZcImIiIiIiIjoL40BgIiIiIiIiOgUYAAgIiIiIiIiOgUYAIiIiIiIiIhOAQYAIiIiIiIiolOAAYCIiIiIiIjoFGAAICIiIiIiIjoFGACIiIiIiIiITgEGACIiIiIiIqJT4P8BJ4EGCIL7pekAAAAASUVORK5CYII=

Since the concepts in the ELI model can be used even if ELI is not implemented in the given Member State the following concepts were removed: cccev:ReferenceFrankework epo-acc:Legistion epo-acc:Article.

Subcriterion

+AAAANtCAAAAAAAABBEEAAAAAABAEEEAAAAAAAAEEQQAAAAAAEAQQQAAAAAAAAQRBAAAAAAAQBBBAAAAAAAABBEEAAAAAABAEEEAAAAAAAAEkY8euZYBAAAAACBIIAAAAAAAAIIIAgAAAAAAIIggAAAAAAAAgggCAAAAAAAgiCAAAAAAAACCCAIAAAAAACCIIAAAAAAAAIIIAgAAAAAAIIggAAAAAAAAgggCAAAAAAAgiCAAAAAAAACCCAIAAAAAACCIIAAAAAAAAIIIAgAAAAAAIIh8tLqyBAAAAAAAQQIBAAAAAAAQRBAAAAAAAABBBAEAAAAAABBEEAAAAAAAAEEEAQAAAAAAEEQQAAAAAAAAQQQBAAAAAAAQRP4PgV63x0zaSCAAAAAASUVORK5CYII=

As the subcriterions ar only used for National Criterion it was decided to change the predicate epo-acc:hasSubcriterion to epo-acc:includesNationalCriterion.

Information Requirement: Requirements and questions

To simplify the reading of the model for business people, it was decided to create specialisations of the CCCEV concepts.
If an entity needs to exist you need explicity to show it. An entity should be a whole.

wfObsGdbMnQygAAAABJRU5ErkJggg==

It was suggested to add a composition relation (the idea of one concept containing another) between:

  • RequirementGroup and Requirement

  • QuestionGroup and Question

However, the composition relation type is not foreseen in model2owl.

Action Point

  • Definitions of all the subclasses added to cccev:InformationRequirement should be discussed

  • Discuss about implementing composition in model2owl

  • Constraints still needs to be modelled